Scroll Saw Vs Band Saw: Experts In Cutting Various Types Of Metals

Tools have also undergone a huge change and have seen technology taking over to make things a lot easier today than it was when such tools were used for the first time.

The saw is one of the most popular tools that is used and has seen technology classifying it into various categories according to the need of the hour. There are various kinds of saws which work for specific reasons.

More...

Introduction

A saw is technically a hand tool that is made of a tough blade, wire or chain. The edges of this tool are sharp and have a tooth like a layout.

The material can be cut when the toothed edge is placed over it and the saw is moved forward and backward by exerting a considerable amount of force. The force that has to be applied is done in different ways depending on the exact type of saw that is being used.

The forces may be derived from hand or it may be powered with the help of steam, water, electricity or any other similar source.Specialty saws are being manufactured to serve a particular purpose.

Closeup side view of a mid 30's man doing some carpentry work at a workshop.

Scroll Saws and Band Saws are popular tools which are very much in demand in the current scenario. But people often find difficulties in determining when to use - a scroll saw or a band saw. To understand that and declare a sure winner of scroll saw vs band saw we have to get an idea about the layout and the basic purpose of these two types of saws.

A scroll saw is a small sized electrically operated saw that is mainly used for the purpose of wood, metal or other similar kinds of materials. The blade is carved in such a manner which lets it be used with more finesse than a power saw.

It is capable of creating carves with the edges that it possesses. A Band Saw is a bit larger in size when compared to a scroll saw. It consists of a band of toothed material that goes across from one end to another to cut material.

They are effective in wood works, metal works and other similar lines of works. These are experts in cutting various types of metals.

Functions

A scroll saw is used mostly when you want that particular jigsaw puzzle to be carved out or you want to carve out a sculpture for your art competition in school. The accuracy of these saws is what makes them unique.

It would provide you with the perfect cuts with less sand scattered all over the floor. Scroll saws use foot pedals to operate the motor, which enables you to freely handle the material.

When you are cutting across a small material,, more precision along with extreme levels of concentration from the person who is carving it are required. On the other hand, band saws are mostly used by professional artists who delve in wood works or activities related to such kind of materials.

The band saw is a more versatile option and is well equipped to go through special kinds of cuts. These saws are adjustable vertically so you can cut through larger materials in a lot lesser time than your traditional saws.

The speed along with the accuracy these saws come with are the biggest advantages of this kind of saws. If the cuts at your materials are needed at odd and difficult angles, this saw is well versed in doing the job.

When you are using a band saw, your hands are free to handle the material and have a greater level of control in what you are trying to achieve. Scroll Saw vs Band Saw is definitely a battle to watch out for:

Some of the popular scroll saws 

Dewalt DW788 1.3 Amp 20 inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw

Dewalt tools have a name in the market and you can hardly put a foot wrong with this range of products. The key features of this product include tool-free blade clamps, double parallel-link arm design to reduce vibration, on off switch, arm pivots etc.

DEWALT DW788 1.3 Amp 20-Inch Variable-Speed Scroll Saw via Amazon


Shop Fox W1713 16 inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw

DEWALT DW788 1.3 Amp 20-Inch Variable-Speed Scroll Saw via Amazon

This is a scroll saw for all those who are looking for one at a budget. Though it comes at a low budget but it does not compromise on its features. Some of its key features include variable motor speed, cast iron table, gooseneck work light, dust blower and dust port, ability to cut across different angles and a table lock knob and tilt scales.


Delta Power Tools 40-694 20 Inch variable Speed Scroll Saw

The electronic speed can be adjusted from 400-1,750 SPM for an array of applications. There is reduced vibration thanks to the dual parallel design and undercutting which improves accuracy and quality. The upper arm lifts and locks in a raised position during adjustment of blade position.

Shop Fox W1713 16-Inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw via Amazon

Some of the popular band saws 

Shop Fox W1706 14-inch Band Saw with Cast Iron Wheels

Shop Fox is well known for having a wide range of tools for most applications. This product boasts of a 1 horsepower single phase motor operating at 1725 Revolutions per minute(RPM).

Shop Fox W1706 14" Bandsaw With Cast Iron Wheels & Deluxe Aluminum Fence via Amazon

The entire structure of this device is made out of durable cast iron. There is a cabin which can be used for storage. A 4 inch dust port comes with it which when connected to a dust collection system keeps the system in perfect working condition.

It has a blade size of 93-1/2 inch and a table size of 14 inch to 14 inch.


Ryobi 2.5-Amp Band Saw

Ryobi ZRBS904G 2.5 Amp 9 in. Portable Band Saw via Amazon

This is a band saw that you will get on a budget. This one is one of the only solutions of this product at such a price range.

It works well for a variety of woodworking applications. It has a blade trading window and a rack and pinion blade support adjustment system. It has a 3-1/2 inch capacity for versatile use. It has a rapid set blade tensioning system which makes it a great buy.


Jet JWBS-14 DXPRO 14-inch Deluxe Pro Band Saw Kit

JET JWBS-14DXPRO 14-Inch Deluxe Pro Band Saw Kit via Amazon

This 14 inch saw has been designed keeping in mind the people involved in the process of wood working. Adding a riser block may not be required as it comes with a cast iron frame which enhances power and performance.

It has many innovative features including a new high tension spring design. With a cutting depth of 90 inches it comes across as a great performer. It has 12 different cutting angles and blade size of 93-105 x 1/8-3/8.

The upper and lower cast iron frame helps to achieve increased rigidity and strength.

Final Verdict

We have clearly distinguished between the features of these two types of saws and which one is capable of performing which tasks. The above discussion, I believe, would give you the sense of choice between these two saws.

You need to check the latest designs at your home and office to make the correct choice between the scroll saw and the band saw.

The ones which have the better patterns and designs are surely going to catch your eye but first, make sure if that appliance is capable of satisfying your purpose.

Woodworkers have a great set of band saws in their armory of power tools since they have to deal with various clients who have varied expectations from them.

Band Saw via Baileigh

On the other hand, those who cultivate it as a hobby or to just pick up the traits, the scroll saws would be the more preferred choice.

They can earn after selling their paintings, wood works and similar works of art. Beginners can get a taste of how the scroll saws and band saws work so that they can get an idea and work on their mistakes. On the whole, the pit against each other may be summarized as follows:

  • For small and intricate wood works, scroll saws are the go-to choice.
  • Band saws will be user-friendly as the users get full control of the materials and access to these devices.
  • Scroll saws come at a budget price and provide great tools for craft work, decoration stuff, making banners, posters etc.
  • Band saws are expensive but if you are on the lookout you may come across some great deals.

So look out for the preferred kind of saw that would fulfill your purpose. There is nothing called as the best. It all boils down to your requirements and how you wish to use the particular product. Good luck with your work.

About the Author Kevin Smith

Hi, i'm a coffee addicted guy and i love my home so that i create this website to discuss about luxury home stuff and how to improve our lifestyle with stuffs.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: